The Obvious Wins Again: Natural Immunity Superior to Vaccine Immunity

The CDC is waging a war against its own credibility by refusing to accept natural immunity

Does a Covid-19 vaccine provide better immunity than prior infection?  While the pundits debated, the Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) got to the bottom of this question.  It engaged in a formal exchange with the CDC on this precise question.  The unsurprising answer – natural immunity wins! 

The exchange, while long, is definitely worth the read.  In short – and this is going to be an understatement – the CDC fails to rebut the clear, consistent, and irrefutable science demonstrating the superiority of natural immunity compared to vaccine immunity.  In sum:

  • Who is more likely to get Covid-19 (the symptomatic disease)?  The answer is clear.  Natural immunity provides greater than 99% protection against Covid-19 while vaccine immunity is well below this level of protection even directly after vaccination and from there rapidly wanes.

  • Who is more likely to become infected with and transmit the virus (with or without symptoms)?  The answer is again crystal clear.  Vaccine immunity does not prevent infection and transmission, while natural immunity does.  As the Director of the CDC explained, the vaccinated need to wear masks because, “what [the COVID-19 vaccines] can’t do anymore is prevent transmission.”  (This point is also covered in a prior article.)

  • Worse, based on official government data from the UK and Israel, the known adverse events from Covid-19 vaccine exceed the known benefits of vaccinating the naturally immune.  See the exchange with the CDC linked above.

The CDC also does not provide a shred of evidence to contest that “after a world-wide hunt for any case of reinfection and transmission of SARS-CoV2, there is no evidence that an individual previously infected with SARS-CoV-2 is at risk of becoming re-infected and transmitting it to others.”  (emphasis in original).  The CDC even has a detailed protocol for investigating reinfections.  But yet is content to crush the rights of those with natural immunity unless they submit to its vaccine policies without documented cases of reinfection and transmission. 

The lesson yet again is not that health authorities should never make mistakes.  They will.  It happens.  The lesson is that civil and individual rights should never be contingent upon a medical procedure.  Everyone, the naturally immune or otherwise, who wants to get vaccinated and boosted should be free to do so.  But nobody should be coerced by the government to partake in any medical procedure.  

Petition to the CDC

CDC’s Response

Reply to CDC

Addendum: Discussing this exchange on Fox News:

Important postscript:  For those that don’t yet know about ICAN, you should.  Let me introduce ICAN this way: we all want safer consumer products, right?  Safer cars.  Safer planes.  Safer toys.  Safer drugs.  Well, what about safer vaccines?  You know, the consumer products that are literally injected into the body.  ICAN has, for over five years, been at the forefront of fighting for safer vaccines for everyone and my firm has been fortunate to be ICAN’s primary legal counsel in this ongoing battle.